Index: utils/ofhttp/OFHTTP.m
==================================================================
--- utils/ofhttp/OFHTTP.m
+++ utils/ofhttp/OFHTTP.m
@@ -50,10 +50,11 @@
 #import "OFOpenItemFailedException.h"
 #import "OFOutOfRangeException.h"
 #import "OFReadFailedException.h"
 #import "OFResolveHostFailedException.h"
 #import "OFSetItemAttributesFailedException.h"
+#import "OFTLSHandshakeFailedException.h"
 #import "OFUnsupportedProtocolException.h"
 #import "OFWriteFailedException.h"
 
 #import "ProgressBar.h"
 
@@ -858,10 +859,26 @@
 			    @"  In order to download via HTTPS, you need to "
 			    @"either build ObjFW with TLS\n"
 			    @"  support or preload a library adding TLS "
 			    @"support to ObjFW!",
 			    @"prog", [OFApplication programName])];
+		} else if ([exception isKindOfClass:
+		    [OFTLSHandshakeFailedException class]]) {
+			OFString *error = OFTLSStreamErrorCodeDescription(
+			    ((OFTLSHandshakeFailedException *)exception)
+			    .errorCode);
+
+			if (!_quiet)
+				[OFStdOut writeString: @"\n"];
+
+			[OFStdErr writeLine: OF_LOCALIZED(
+			    @"download_failed_tls_handshake_failed",
+			    @"%[prog]: Failed to download <%[iri]>!\n"
+			    @"  TLS handshake failed: %[error]",
+			    @"prog", [OFApplication programName],
+			    @"iri", request.IRI.string,
+			    @"error", error)];
 		} else if ([exception isKindOfClass:
 		    [OFReadOrWriteFailedException class]]) {
 			OFString *error = OF_LOCALIZED(
 			    @"download_failed_read_or_write_failed_any",
 			    @"Read or write failed");

Index: utils/ofhttp/localization/de.json
==================================================================
--- utils/ofhttp/localization/de.json
+++ utils/ofhttp/localization/de.json
@@ -58,10 +58,14 @@
         "Unterstützung\n",
         "  kompilieren oder eine Bibliothek mittels „preload” laden, welche ",
         "TLS-Support\n",
         "  zu ObjFW hinzufügt!"
     ],
+    "download_failed_tls_handshake_failed": [
+        "%[prog]: Fehler beim Download von <%[iri]>!\n",
+        "  TLS-Handshake fehlgeschlagen: %[error]"
+    ],
     "download_failed_read_or_write_failed_any": "Lesen oder Schreiben",
     "download_failed_read_or_write_failed_read": "Lesen",
     "download_failed_read_or_write_failed_write": "Schreiben",
     "download_failed_read_or_write_failed": [
         "%[prog]: Fehler beim Download von <%[iri]>!\n",